Robert Hughes: Barcelona

I have not found a good description of the book, so I paste an average comment explaining it is good but scholary. I’m affraid I do not have big expectations of this book (so thick and with a really small letters), so maybe this is the best way to start…

Have a good summer all of you!



Beautiful city, scholarly book,September 19, 2004

C. B Collins Jr. (Atlanta, GA United States)
This review is from: Barcelona (Paperback)

I visited Barcelona in 1982 and then again, 20 years later, in 2002. I am certainly glad I read Robert Hughes’ “Barcelona” before going the second time since it certainly gave me a new perspective on the city, its history, its art, and its architecture.

The history of the Catalunya area is fascinating, an area that predates the Roman Empire. Two Roman Emperors came from Barcelona, Trajan and his nephew Hadrian. Hughes helps us understand the unique development of the Catalan language, culture, history which is frequently at odds with Madrid and Spain’s central government.

Hughes does an excellent job of mapping the development of city with changes in politics and the coming of the industrial revolution. At one point, Barcelona was filled with sweat shops, offering long 12 hour days, very low wages, unhealthy nasty work conditions, deprivation of exercise and light, and explotative child labor. As I walked the city of Barceona, I imagined the struggling families trying to survive under these conditions in times past.

Even though the full 574 pages are engaging in this long book, the chapters on Gaudi are the strongest, most enjoyable, and most insightful. If pressed for time before taking a tripto Spain, I would strongly recommend reading the sections on Gaudi before seeing his actual works which are spread out all over the city of Barcelona.

The concept that was fascinating to me was Hughes’ explanation that Gaudi’s work was in fact very conservative rather than radical. His work is based on a return to the natural object, the shell,the wing, the tail, the spine, the leaf, the root. His work takes these natural objects and reduces to essential form and then expands again from that essential form with texture, color, and sensitivity to the material and physicality of the medium. This explains the amazing popularity among the Japanese for the work of Gaudi, which philosophically and esthetically is more in line with Japanese culture and esthetics. Knowing this before seeing his Cathedral, parks, and residences gave me a completely new appreciation for Gaudi and the city in which he created his masterpieces.

One response

  1. Hi, Ramon. Thanks for the introduction.
    Once we forget about searching for Literature (with big “L”), I have to say we have been given a very good book, in the “content” sense, not in the forms or concepts.
    Maybe it is a personal feeling (even all feelings are personal) but this book has come to complement my low knowledge of Barcelona’s history, even I’ve been living there since 1972 (we went to Torrelles in 1992). I knew all the names of all the streets of GrĂ cia, but never minded about who Torras i Bages was, except an ugly metro station around Meridiana. And I’ve discovered, thanks to Andrea and Helena, that I like to know those details now. I used to go to Joan Guell street behind Corte Ingles Diagonal, but now it is the father of Eusebi Guell who has captured my interests.
    Sure thera are lots of items described in the book we already know, but I am sure there are plenty we did not and I find quite funny most of them.
    Here in Torrelles the “fil.loxera” killed the grapes in the still called “vinyes” where now we have “cirerers”, so we are part of this history as well.
    I am really enjoying 19th century – the Universal Exposition of 1888 (page 375) is so similar to 1992 Olimpic Games …
    Lets see if we get more comments in this blog this summer …

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: